U.S. Loyalty Programs Get More Funding but Fall Short on Delivery
Businesses are boosting loyalty program investment, but a wide gap remains between consumer expectations and actual rewards experience.
American businesses are ramping up spending on customer loyalty programs, yet a significant disconnect persists between what consumers expect and what those programs actually deliver, according to new research from arrivia released Monday.
The survey found that nine in ten U.S. consumers expect to remain loyal to their preferred brand or organization — a figure that signals strong baseline attachment across industries. Despite that goodwill, only 32% of respondents said their loyalty program consistently exceeds expectations, leaving the vast majority feeling underserved by the very initiatives designed to retain them.
Read more EFICYENT to Join Global Fintech Leaders at Singapore FinTech Festival 2026 →
The findings point to a structural challenge for companies pouring resources into retention: increased investment alone does not guarantee stronger member satisfaction. The gap between loyalty intent and program performance suggests that design, relevance, and reward value may matter more than the sheer volume of spending behind these initiatives.
For loyalty program operators, the arrivia data underscores an urgency to rethink how rewards are structured and communicated. With consumer expectations climbing alongside corporate budgets, the margin for programs that merely meet the bar — rather than surpass it — appears to be narrowing.
Continue reading at All Financial Services & Investing.